Non-Religious but born Muslim, in love with a Hindu boy. Help?

So I am half Kuwaiti Arab half American born and raised in the USA. I've never really felt a connection with the Islamic religion, most of it I know is cultural attachment. Anyway, because of this I have slowly drifted away from it because I'm an outspoken female with a love for being strange and different. So I don't know what to do because my dad is super strict religious and I'm pretty sure he already hates me just cause i play sports and for the way I dress and talk. But I kind of don't want to piss him off more. So I don't know what to do because he expects me to marry a Muslim man, which I never ever ever want to do. He even speaks of how he should have sent me away to Kuwait when I was younger. Which that leads me to my other issue of being in love with a Hindu boy. We dated awhile back but broke it off because "it would never work" but we couldn't stay away from each other and we are "best friends" even though we act like a couple. All of our friends make fun of us cause they say we act like we're married. But I was just looking to see people's opinion on these matters and what I should do.